Experiment setup

I compared the two microphones that come with the Zoom H6 recorder—an X-Y cardioid pair and a Mid-Side (MS) Blumlein configuration—to a Shure KSM141 Stereo Pair, also in an X-Y configuration. The purpose of this exercise was to learn how to use the H6, and to decide which microphones I want to use to record the next concert. All mics were essentially at the same position, and the Zoom H6 was set to use 48-kHz sample rates and 24-bits of resolution. I postprocessed the .wav files using Audacity and exported them as lossless Ogg-Vorbis files.

I recorded three selections: orchestral, percussion, and chamber music to exercise the microphones. To my ears, the Shure mics have the best bass, but seem to have more echo. Also note that the Sibelius recording is 24-bit, which eliminates  the graininess you may hear in the strings in the other 16-bit recordings.

Any background noises come from me moving or touching things, so ignore them. You may have to use Google Chrome to play the Ogg files.

Microphone Comparisons

  Zoom H6 X-Y Zoom H6 MS Shure KSM141
Rachmaninov, Sergei

Symphonic Dances

Eduardo Mata, Dallas Symphony
RachDancesX-Y RachDancesMS RachDancesShure
Hill, Dave
Escape Velocity

Brian White

TCU Percussion Ensemble
EscapeVelocityX-Y EscapeVelocityMS EscapeVelocityShure
Shostakovich, Dmitri

String Quartet No. 6:

I. Allegretto

Fitzwilliam String Quartet
ShostSQ6X-Y ShostSQ6MS ShostSQ6Shure

Sibelius, Jean
Symphony No. 3:
III. Moderato - Allegro ma non tanto

Osmo Vanska
Minneapolis Symphony
(24-bit recording)

Sibelius3X-Y Sibelius3MS Sibelius3Shure

I have now had a chance to video live performances using the Zoom H6, and a season's worth of performances are online . Early on, I used both the Zoom H6 in MS mode, and my two Shure KSM141 as a crossed pair at the same location. You can see the microphone location in the above videos. I them listen to the two different audio tracks, both recorded on the H6 at 48 kHz and 24 bits. I always prefer the H6 MS, which I then put into the videos (for the past year) that are on YouTube. Earlier videos probably used the Shures.

The reason for my choice is that the MS microphone is unbeaten for stereo imaging. With the MS, you can visualize the whole performing group. The only real advantage the Shures have is better low bass. Kettle drums on the H6 sound a bit wimpy.

Which microphone sounds best?

Choices

Comments

Submitted by jarome on Wed, 04/19/2017 - 06:58

Permalink

I have not made that comparison directly. But to me, the Shure pair of mics always beats the Zoom H6 x-y pair, especially in the bass region.  I doubt that the AT2022 would improve on the Zoom in a noticeable manner. 

<p>Thanks for your answer. Do you have tested the Rode NT4 ?</p>

<p>Thanks in advance.&nbsp;</p>

Add new comment

Comment

  • No HTML tags allowed.
CAPTCHA This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.